(no subject)
Jan. 30th, 2026 12:40 pmBut I largely had a good time?? Hobb's emotional beats DID get me. I got gotten. The pacing is slow, but I was always stressed and happy and sad and moved when she wanted me to be, and her prose is stronger than readable. There aren't many women, but they're all people, and I did love them, from Patience, his weird and mean sort-of-stepmom who has ADHD to Selene, girl who responds to brainwashing by being brainwashed.
In fact, everyone who is remotely on Fitz's side is interesting, even though--or even because!--most of them hurt or disappoint him. Actually, that's not fair. They're frequently legitimately interesting on their own, outside of how they hurt Fitz. Molly, I love you. Burrichs, you gave [spoilers] an earring?
I read a reddit post that complained about Fitz being pummeled continuously by the narrative, and it made me worried that this would be a wet cat hurt/comfort thing. This was concerning, since I'd recently read Lackey's Magic's Pawn for the first time and found the experience repulsive. But it's not! Fitz absolutely is pummeled, but people don't magically become nicer to him. Thank god.
Obviously, preferring pummeling to comfort is a wildly personal preference I don't have to discuss with anyone but my therapist, but I think there's something in that--in that the interiorities of the other characters don't respond magically to Fitz's own--that has to be why I liked this book as well as I did, even though, in broad strokes, I thought the plot was pretty stupid?
For indeed, I found many things about the book very Funny On Accident and/or Frustrating:
- Shortly after beginning the novel, I found out from multiple friends that Hobb is famous for her homophobic and anti-fanfiction blog posts. I tried not to look them up, but of course I did. Damn, girl! It's a violence to imagine Fitz is gay? Girl you gave him the homosexuality allegory where being a Disney Princess means you're wrong inside. YOU CALLED IT A PERVERSION, AND YOU ALSO GAVE IT TO THE MOST REPRESSED MAN I'VE READ IN AGES WHO LITERALLY TELLS FITZ "well you can have the urges just don't act on them" GIRL????? Funny as hell. Robin I'm very sorry you can't read but the text called, and it told me they're gay
- The Forged Ones are video game antagonists. She pretends that they say something about What It Means To Be Human, but they don't... they're off-screen mobs... Every time she tried to get some sort of aphoristic proclamation out of them I had to close the book and complain to Becca or Kirby. There's ALSO this weird moment where Molly experiences profound grief, and Fitz is like "she disappeared from my senses... like she was a Forged One...." Robin I understand that you're trying to say something about the self-annihilation experienced in extreme grief, but I think "strong grief makes you inhuman" is not what you meant? Please be careful with metaphors.
- i cannot believe how much shrewd has to carry the idiot ball through the back half. i'm a great, astute leader! i love buying necklaces for my son with money we could use to defend the towns. ROBIN I LITERALLY DONT BELIEVE YOU. I READ THE FIRST 200 PAGES AND I DONT BELIEVE YOU
- Royal is also boring. She will KEEP telling us that he's good at shit, but it's all off-screen, so mostly we see him do mean girlisms. again: i don't believe you
- actually all the villains are boring. what do they want? idk. to rule??? Galen the cult leader is almost interesting, but honestly his hate hard-on for Fitz is so protagonist-coded it's also boring. why is she sooo bad at showing-not-telling her antagonists when she's so good at it for everyone else
- Speaking of Galen, we WILL be weird about bodies. We are inventing new ways to be weird about bodies so you can know this skinny man is evil
- there is ONE naming scheme in this world. things are named what they are. warm bay. nailed it






